Warning: ob_start() [ref.outcontrol]: output handler 'ob_gzhandler' conflicts with 'zlib output compression' in /home/windsof/public_html/archives/007080.php on line 1
Winds of Change.NET: Property Rights & Justice Souter: Sauce for the Gander?
Winds of Change.NET: Liberty. Discovery. Humanity. Victory.



Formal Affiliations

Anti-Idiotarian Manifesto
Euston Democratic Progressive Manifesto
Real Democracy for Iran!
Support Denamrk
Million Voices for Darfur
milblogs
Prev | List | Random | Next | Join
Powered by RingSurf!

e-Syndication

June 28, 2005

Property Rights & Justice Souter: Sauce for the Gander?

by Joe Katzman at June 28, 2005 9:27 PM

I thought this was entertaining. Via Rantburg, thanks to a tip from reader Tom Pechinski:

"Justice Souter's vote in the "Kelo vs. City of New London" decision allows city governments to take land from one private owner and give it to another if the government will generate greater tax revenue or other economic benefits when the land is developed by the new owner.

On Monday June 27, Logan Darrow Clements, faxed a request to Chip Meany the code enforcement officer of the Towne of Weare, New Hampshire seeking to start the application process to build a hotel on 34 Cilley Hill Road. This is the present location of Mr. Souter's home."

Wait, it gets better...

"Clements, CEO of Freestar Media, LLC, points out that the City of Weare will certainly gain greater tax revenue and economic benefits with a hotel on 34 Cilley Hill Road than allowing Mr. Souter to own the land.

The proposed development, called "The Lost Liberty Hotel" will feature the "Just Desserts Cafe" and include a museum, open to the public, featuring a permanent exhibit on the loss of freedom in America. Instead of a Gideon's Bible each guest will receive a free copy of Ayn Rand's novel "Atlas Shrugged."

Great joke, right? Uh...

"This is not a prank" said Clements, "The Towne of Weare has five people on the Board of Selectmen. If three of them vote to use the power of eminent domain to take this land from Mr. Souter we can begin our hotel development."

Ongoing updates can be found at the FreeStar Media web site.

I'm an original intent kind of guy, and I'm not conversant with the legal arguments. It's possible that the decision in Kelo was unfortunate but the only one that could be supported based on what the state of the law is (though Justice Thomas' well-written dissent suggests probably not).

All I know is, expropriating someone's home to give to a commercial developer is wrong, wrong, wrong - an abuse of a sovereign people, and one of the biggest invitations to corruption I have ever seen. So it will be a ton of fun to follow this one. Normally I'm pretty sympathetic to the idea that public officials must not be harassed in the performance of their duties - but in this case, the punishment definitely fits the crime.

At the very least, it should get some great and thought-provoking publicity if they muster the Board of Selectmen votes. Maybe it will even a few people to consider the merits of studying libertarian legal theory in law schools, as a much-needed counterbalance and perspective.

I should add that there is no such thing as property rights in Canada. Mind you, there are an awful lot of rights and safeguards that don't exist in Canada (Hat Tip: Jack "Zed" Zidaric).

UPDATE: Democratic House Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) doesn't seem to get.... well, a lot of things.


TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.windsofchange.net/windsopcentre-cms/trackback.cgi/4834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
"Property Rights & Justice Souter: Sauce for the Gander?"
Tracked: June 28, 2005 10:41 PM
Excerpt: ... Needless to say, this is upsetting. One man has proposed that we start with Justice Souter's house...
Tracked: June 29, 2005 2:02 AM
Dinner at Just Desserts Cafe? from No Pundit Intended
Excerpt: From Rantburg via Winds of Change Weare, New Hampshire (PRWEB) Could a hotel be built on the land owned by Supre
Tracked: June 29, 2005 1:42 PM
The Lost Liberty Hotel from Danny Carlton (aka Jack Lewis)
Excerpt: From Freestar Media: On Monday June 27, Logan Darrow Clements, faxed a request to Chip Meany the code enforcement officer...
Tracked: July 1, 2005 4:15 AM
Excerpt: It would appear that the great and good Joe Katzman disagrees with me and appears to think that it would be just desserts if Justice Souter lost his house as a result of the exercise of eminent domain. From this...

Comments
#1 from Robert M at 9:56 pm on Jun 28, 2005

LOL Who does not believe in kharma now?

#2 from Khash at 10:24 pm on Jun 28, 2005

Joe
You might like this story though

http://reformjudaismmag.org/Articles/index.cfm?id=1012

#3 from PD Shaw at 10:54 pm on Jun 28, 2005

The tyranny of the majority indeed.

"In all cases where a majority are united by a common interest or passion, the rights of the minority are in danger."

"[A] pure democracy…can admit of no cure for the mischiefs of [the majority]…and there is nothing to check the inducements to sacrifice the weaker party. Hence it is that such democracies have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal securities or the right of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths."

James Madison

#4 from Ruth at 12:24 am on Jun 29, 2005

On the Texas-Oklahoma border Lake Texoma covers the former sites of three small towns, an Indian village and much rich farmland that the owners did not part with willingly. As a matter of fact, my father was run off with guns more than once while appraising the lands to estimate their monetary value in order to make those purchases.

Truthfully, I've always hated the thought that those honest people were pushed off their land, although I do understand the need for the water. Lake Texoma provides water to a lot of relatively parched towns in that area.

Eminent domain needs to be exercised with very great discretion.

#5 from FFE at 12:26 am on Jun 29, 2005

Hey, does anyone have a copy of the prospectus? Maybe we could send courtesy copies to the 4 who voted against Kelo.

#6 from Joe A at 10:37 am on Jun 29, 2005

With such rulings, who needs a Socialist party?

Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Tax Revenue

How many million deaths have caused the good of the community?

#7 from lurker at 3:11 pm on Jun 29, 2005

The difference with Lake Texoma is that it truly serves a public function.

Our president could tell us the difference between that and the deal that the Texas Rangers got when folks were forced to sell their property for a ballpark that was turned over to the privately owned ballclub. Whatever Bush is, his libertarian streak is quite small.

#8 from Ruth at 3:38 pm on Jun 29, 2005

True, lurker, good point - but the effect on the homeowner who sought out his/her place and put up a home on it, is the same.

And in suburban Dallas, the Cowboys are taking by eminent domain some little shops and homes to build a new stadium - leaving a facility that they won't negotiate with their former home in Irving, TX, to improve, thereby also depriving people who established businesses that counted on their presence there.

It would seem that giving dominant powers to corporate entities is not the best choice of means of protecting public interests.

Rep. Ted Poe of TX stood up in Congress today and noted that Justice Souter's home is the object of a newly instituted eminent domain effort in NH. He didn't smirk when he said it, though.

#9 from lurker at 3:53 pm on Jun 29, 2005

Ruth,
I agree with you. Forceably taking property from private citizens is NEVER a good thing to the victims. Eminent domain has always been the law of the land. The state shold exercise this power with care and only rarely, and NEVER for the benefit of any other private party. If the state takes property, it should be for state uses and not private ones.

I lived in Dallas for 14 years and the deal with the Rangers still rankles. It was how George W. Bush, as minority owner and supposedly a conservative, made most of his money. A gifted stadium is a sweet deal alright. Compared to this, Hillary's profit on beef futures doesn't even rate a blip. I'm not in the least surprised that the Cowboys are now feeding at the same trough.

#10 from Joe Katzman at 9:12 pm on Jun 29, 2005

The Dallas Cowboys too, huh... doesn't that violate the laws against separation of Church and State?

#11 from Ruth at 9:47 pm on Jun 29, 2005

Smile when you say that. (as we say around the ol' corral).

lurker, remember they've been having losing seasons lately. Some of the excess may be going off shore ... oops, heresy.

#12 from Ari Tai at 1:16 am on Jun 30, 2005

If Clements did an IPO for a business around this (say, targeting the homes and other real-estate owned by our hundred Senators), I'd happily make a sizable investment (as large or larger than what I give to the IJ who are fighting the good fight).

#13 from Joe Katzman at 8:47 pm on Jul 02, 2005

(Added here because we're having technical problems with some posts):

Democratic House Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) doesn't seem to get.... well, a lot of things.

Post a comment

Here are some quick tips for adding simple Textile formatting to your comments, though you can also use proper HTML tags:

*This* puts text in bold.

_This_ puts text in italics.

bq. This "bq." at the beginning of a paragraph, flush with the left hand side and with a space after it, is the code to indent one paragraph of text as a block quote.

To add a live URL, "Text to display":http://windsofchange.net/ (no spaces between) will show up as Text to display. Always use this for links - otherwise you will screw up the columns on our main blog page.

Finally, note that a constant onslaught of Trackback spams from auto-generated blogspot blogs has forced Winds to ban the blogspot.com domain from use in comments or trackbacks. If you host on blogspot, consider moving; otherwise, the complaints need to be directed at Google not us.










Archives By Category
-FEATURES: 48 Ways to Wisdom (24)
-FEATURES: Diaries & Roundups (10)
-FEATURES: Military Transformation Uplink (12)
-FEATURES: New Energy Currents (20)
-FEATURES: Reader Highlights (2)
-FEATURES: Regional Briefings (166)
-FEATURES: Sufi Wisdom (158)
-FEATURES: The Bard's Breath (32)
-FEATURES: Winds of Discovery (6)
-FEATURES: Winds of War [WoT] (445)
4 HA: 4th-Gen Warfare (103)
4 HA: al-Qaeda (159)
4 HA: Crime, Organized (26)
4 HA: Evil Exists (111)
4 HA: Intelligence/Spycraft (100)
4 HA: Military (531)
4 HA: Nukes, Poisons, Germs (136)
4 HA: Statecraft (29)
4 HA: War on Terror articles (709)
Best Of... (180)
BIZ: Business & Organizations (137)
BIZ: Economics (103)
BIZ: Energy (75)
CIVIS (236)
CIVIS: Copyright Wars (25)
CIVIS: Drug Wars (18)
CIVIS: Edu-Kooks (76)
CIVIS: Free Societies (296)
CIVIS: Hall of Shame (164)
CIVIS: Hatred Rising (114)
CIVIS: Journalism & Media (413)
CIVIS: Spirit of America.NET (32)
CIVIS: War Within the West (313)
COLUMNISTS: M. Simon (13)
COLUMNISTS: Tarek Heggy (33)
GEO: Afghanistan (80)
GEO: Africa (104)
GEO: Asia (117)
GEO: Aussies & Kiwis (22)
GEO: Canada (72)
GEO: China (87)
GEO: Europe (183)
GEO: France (71)
GEO: India-Pakistan (113)
GEO: Iran (224)
GEO: Iraq (967)
GEO: Israel (249)
GEO: Koreas (64)
GEO: Latin America (63)
GEO: Middle East (257)
GEO: Russia (83)
GEO: Saudi Arabia (64)
GEO: Sudan (36)
GEO: U.K. (71)
GEO: U.N. (61)
GEO: U.S. of A (506)
HUMANITY (89)
HUMANITY: Art & Culture (161)
HUMANITY: Art - Music (32)
HUMANITY: Art - Poetry (6)
HUMANITY: Christianity (53)
HUMANITY: Heroes & Achievements (232)
HUMANITY: History (126)
HUMANITY: Islam (183)
HUMANITY: Judaism (137)
HUMANITY: Love (32)
HUMANITY: Philosophy (49)
HUMANITY: Spirituality & Religion (74)
HUMANITY: Zen & Buddhism (28)
Humour (200)
Misc. (44)
NET: Blogosphere (397)
NET: Cyber-Security (16)
NET: Grid Computing (3)
NET: Spam (24)
NET: The Internet (39)
NET: The Open Source Meme (18)
Personal (199)
SCI-TECH: Biotech & Medical (84)
SCI-TECH: Eco-tech (82)
SCI-TECH: Nanotech (27)
SCI-TECH: Science (113)
SCI-TECH: Space (75)
SCI-TECH: Technology (146)
SPORTS (45)
SPORTS: Baseball (76)
Trends (66)
USA: America Catch-all (20)
USA: Anti-Americanism (6)
USA: California Politics (16)
USA: Conservatives & GOP (43)
USA: Dem Party Renewal (77)
USA: Domestic Issues (56)
USA: Elections (132)
USA: Grand Strategy (15)
USA: Homeland Security (106)
VictoryPAC (3)
Winds of Change.NET (56)

Archives by Date
Winds Blogroll



Recent Entries

Support Winds of Change.NET!


Your support & assistance is greatly appreciated, and makes a difference!
The Winds Crew:

Town Founder:
Joe Katzman
joe {at} windsofchange. net
Joe's Normblog Interview

Left-Hand Man:
Marc 'Armed Liberal' Danziger
armed {at} windsofchange. net
A.L.'s Normblog Interview

Other Winds Marshals
'AMac', aka. Marshal Festus (AMac@...)
Robin "Straight Shooter" Burk
'Cicero', aka. The Quiet Man (cicero@...)
David Blue (david.blue@...)
'Lewy14', aka. Marshal Leroy (lewy14@...)
'Nortius Maximus', aka. Big Tuna (nortius.maximus@...)

Other Regulars
'Callimachus' (callimachus@...)
'Demosophist' (demosophist@...)
Rev./Maj. Donald Sensing
'Molon Labe' (molon.labe@...)
'Neo Neo-Con'
Tarek Heggy (tarek@...)

Semi-Active:
Arthur Chrenkoff
'Gabriel Gonzalez' (in Paris)
Tim Oren (tim@...)
Trent Telenko (trent@...)

Posting Affiliates
Athena: Terrorism Unveiled
Chester: The Adventures of Chester
Dave Schuler: The Glittering Eye
Grim: Grim's Lair et. al. Joel Gaines [Russia]
Michael Totten
MILblogging.com: The MilBlogs directory
Murdoc [Military]
Situational Awareness team [Military]
Nathan Hamm [Central Asia]
Randy Paul [Latin America]
Robert Koehler [Koreas]
Robi Sen [India & S. Asia]
Nitin Pai [India & S. Asia]
Simon [China & E. Asia]
Yehudit: Kesher Talk

Emeritus:
Adil Farooq (adil@...)
Andrew Olmsted [KIA, Iraq]
Celeste Bilby (celeste@...)
Dan Darling
Gary Farber (gary@...)
Hossein Derakhshan (hoder@...)
T.L. James (tljames@...)
Robin Burk (robin@...)


Winds of Change.NET Blogkids & Affiliates

·
The Argus: covering Central Asia
· Canis Iratus: Glen Wishard
· Correct-Amundo: Tech & society
· Discarded Lies: Ev & Zorkie
· The Flying Kiwi: Donovan Janus
· The Glittering Eye: Dave Schuler
· Gumptionology: Nortius Maximus
· Hot Needle of Inquiry: 'Jinnderella'
· Laughing Wolf: C. Blake Powers
· Out The Mazoo: 'Mazoo'
· Power and Control: M. Simon
· Praktike's Place: 'Praktike'
· Random Probabilities: Robin Burk
· Siberian Light: covering Russia
· The Spirit of Man

· Good News From the Front
· WATCH/: covering the war on terror

Archives By Category
-FEATURES: 48 Ways to Wisdom (24)
-FEATURES: Diaries & Roundups (10)
-FEATURES: Military Transformation Uplink (12)
-FEATURES: New Energy Currents (20)
-FEATURES: Reader Highlights (2)
-FEATURES: Regional Briefings (166)
-FEATURES: Sufi Wisdom (158)
-FEATURES: The Bard's Breath (32)
-FEATURES: Winds of Discovery (6)
-FEATURES: Winds of War [WoT] (445)
4 HA: 4th-Gen Warfare (103)
4 HA: al-Qaeda (159)
4 HA: Crime, Organized (26)
4 HA: Evil Exists (111)
4 HA: Intelligence/Spycraft (100)
4 HA: Military (531)
4 HA: Nukes, Poisons, Germs (136)
4 HA: Statecraft (29)
4 HA: War on Terror articles (709)
Best Of... (180)
BIZ: Business & Organizations (137)
BIZ: Economics (103)
BIZ: Energy (75)
CIVIS (236)
CIVIS: Copyright Wars (25)
CIVIS: Drug Wars (18)
CIVIS: Edu-Kooks (76)
CIVIS: Free Societies (296)
CIVIS: Hall of Shame (164)
CIVIS: Hatred Rising (114)
CIVIS: Journalism & Media (413)
CIVIS: Spirit of America.NET (32)
CIVIS: War Within the West (313)
COLUMNISTS: M. Simon (13)
COLUMNISTS: Tarek Heggy (33)
GEO: Afghanistan (80)
GEO: Africa (104)
GEO: Asia (117)
GEO: Aussies & Kiwis (22)
GEO: Canada (72)
GEO: China (87)
GEO: Europe (183)
GEO: France (71)
GEO: India-Pakistan (113)
GEO: Iran (224)
GEO: Iraq (967)
GEO: Israel (249)
GEO: Koreas (64)
GEO: Latin America (63)
GEO: Middle East (257)
GEO: Russia (83)
GEO: Saudi Arabia (64)
GEO: Sudan (36)
GEO: U.K. (71)
GEO: U.N. (61)
GEO: U.S. of A (506)
HUMANITY (89)
HUMANITY: Art & Culture (161)
HUMANITY: Art - Music (32)
HUMANITY: Art - Poetry (6)
HUMANITY: Christianity (53)
HUMANITY: Heroes & Achievements (232)
HUMANITY: History (126)
HUMANITY: Islam (183)
HUMANITY: Judaism (137)
HUMANITY: Love (32)
HUMANITY: Philosophy (49)
HUMANITY: Spirituality & Religion (74)
HUMANITY: Zen & Buddhism (28)
Humour (200)
Misc. (44)
NET: Blogosphere (397)
NET: Cyber-Security (16)
NET: Grid Computing (3)
NET: Spam (24)
NET: The Internet (39)
NET: The Open Source Meme (18)
Personal (199)
SCI-TECH: Biotech & Medical (84)
SCI-TECH: Eco-tech (82)
SCI-TECH: Nanotech (27)
SCI-TECH: Science (113)
SCI-TECH: Space (75)
SCI-TECH: Technology (146)
SPORTS (45)
SPORTS: Baseball (76)
Trends (66)
USA: America Catch-all (20)
USA: Anti-Americanism (6)
USA: California Politics (16)
USA: Conservatives & GOP (43)
USA: Dem Party Renewal (77)
USA: Domestic Issues (56)
USA: Elections (132)
USA: Grand Strategy (15)
USA: Homeland Security (106)
VictoryPAC (3)
Winds of Change.NET (56)

Archives by Date
Winds Blogroll


Powered by:
LighTTPD web server
Ubuntu Linux
Movable Type
Hosted by Pixelgate