Winds of Change.NET: Department Of "Damn, I Wish I'd Said That...

May 10, 2008

Department Of "Damn, I Wish I'd Said That...

by Armed Liberal at May 10, 2008 4:12 PM

I've been getting more and more into data visualization as an aspect at work (think Tufte), and have started following some of the excellent blogs on the subject. On one of them, Flowing Data, the author just made a point about context - which applies both to my criticisms of newsmedia, and to my efforts to but a basic quantitative frame around some of the policy claims that are made - that is so perfectly written that, to quote Jack Black "You bastard! That's so good - that should have been mine..."

Without further ado, Nathan from Flowing Data:

If I were to skip straight to the part in The Shawshank Redemption when Andy Durfesne climbs out of the pipe of poo (and put it on mute), someone who never saw the movie might see an escaped convict who steals money from a warden and fleas to some random place in Mexico called Zihuatanejo. Out of grief, the warden kills himself and Ellis Boyd "Red" Redding eventually teams up with Andy to commit more crimes.
Those of us who have seen the movie though know this isn't the case. Why? Because we saw the whole movie and have context.
Context Matters
As Andrew, a FlowingData reader, put it, "For statistics to be useful, it needs to be explained in a context." When I get my hands on some data, whether I'm analyzing or visualizing, I want to know the context of data first. I want to know who collected the data, how it was collected, when it was collected, and what was done to it before it arrived in my hands. Without that meta-information, I could easily make an incorrect assumption about the data or misrepresent it somehow in a visualization - which is very bad.
Simply put, we use visualization and statistics to tell stories with data. If we don't have all the information, then we can't tell a complete story.

Can we just tattoo that on the inside of the eyelids of all journalists, commentators, and policymakers?

Printer-friendly Version

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.windsofchange.net/windsopcentre-cms/trackback.cgi/7891

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference
"Department Of "Damn, I Wish I'd Said That..."

Comments

#1 from Demosophist at 8:04 pm on May 10, 2008

Again, the most likely explanation for discrepancies is a reporting effect. More suicides of former military personnel are accurately identified as suicides. The way crime analysis often gets around the reporting effect is to supplement analysis with victim surveys. Clearly there are some problems with using victim surveys to identify the frequency of suicide, especially since being disconnected from family and loved ones is one of the chief risk factors for suicide, and it's hard for suicides to respond to a survey.

#2 from old maltese at 8:05 pm on May 10, 2008

' ... steals money from a warden and fleas'

As Willie Sutton might have said, 'Sometimes you gotta scratch that itch.'

#3 from Glen Wishard at 9:58 pm on May 10, 2008

If we don't have all the information, then we can't tell a complete story.

Yes, but you can tell some really scary stories with incomplete information. Not to mention any names, but if I did, it would be that pasty-faced worthless-ass clown Al G***. And speaking of Al G***, don't you think he should jump into the race and save the Democratic party?

Post a comment

Here are some quick tips for adding simple Textile formatting to your comments, though you can also use proper HTML tags:

*This* puts text in bold.

_This_ puts text in italics.

bq. This "bq." at the beginning of a paragraph, flush with the left hand side and with a space after it, is the code to indent one paragraph of text as a block quote.

To add a live URL, "Text to display":http://windsofchange.net/ (no spaces between) will show up as Text to display. Always use this for links - otherwise you will screw up the columns on our main blog page.

Finally, note that a constant onslaught of Trackback spams from auto-generated blogspot blogs has forced Winds to ban the blogspot.com domain from use in comments or trackbacks. If you host on blogspot, consider moving; otherwise, the complaints need to be directed at Google not us.